cape

The Day I Realized God Never Asked Me to Wear the Cape

November 12, 2026•9 min read

I've been thinking about capes lately.

Not the kind superheroes wear... although I suppose that's exactly where this story begins.

I'm talking about the invisible ones we put on without realizing it.

The cape of being the strong one. The one who keeps everyone happy, anticipates the problems, finds the solutions, and somehow manages to hold everything together.

The one who believes that if she just loves a little harder, prays a little longer, or finds the right words, everything might finally be okay.

I know that cape well.

I've worn it for years.

And if I'm being honest... there have been times when I've been so busy trying to make sure everyone else was okay that I forgot to ask myself if I was.

Recently, while reading Lysa TerKeurst's book Making Peace with What You Cannot Control, I came across her reflection about taking off the cape of control.

Oh, how those words settled into my heart.

Because I recognized something about myself that I hadn't fully understood before.

Sometimes what I call helping is actually my attempt to control an outcome I'm afraid of.

And that's a difficult thing to admit.

I love deeply.

I care about the people in my life.

When someone I love is struggling, my natural instinct is to step in, offer advice, find a solution, or somehow make the situation better.

But what happens when the person we love doesn't want our solution?

What happens when we've said everything we know to say, prayed every prayer we know to pray, and nothing changes?

I've found myself in that place more than once.

Wondering if I should try harder. Say something differently. Give a little more of myself.

And beneath all those questions is one that feels especially tender.

What if I've done everything I can, and it still isn't enough?

I think that's where my need for control often begins.

Not because I want to control people, but because I'm afraid of what might happen if I don't.

Afraid of disappointment.

Afraid of losing something important.

Afraid that the outcome won't look anything like the one I've been praying for.

And perhaps most of all, afraid of not knowing what comes next.

I'm walking through a season of my own life right now where that uncertainty feels especially real.

There are relationships I'm praying over, conversations I'm learning how to navigate, and questions I don't have answers to yet.

Some days I feel peaceful. Other days, my mind wants to race ahead and figure everything out.

I want to know how the story ends before I've even finished living this chapter.

But God keeps bringing me back to something I've been learning for a long time.

Faith was never meant to give me control over the outcome.

Faith invites me to trust the One who can see what I cannot.

I've been thinking about the invitation Jesus gives in Matthew 11:28:

"Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest."

I've loved that scripture for years, but lately I've been wondering if I've missed something in it.

Jesus doesn't ask us to come once we've solved the problem.

He doesn't require us to have our emotions figured out or our relationships perfectly restored.

He simply invites us to come.

And I wonder how often I've stood there holding everything in my arms, asking Him for strength to keep carrying it, when perhaps He was offering to help me put some of it down.

That thought changes something for me.

Because surrender isn't the same as giving up.

I can still love someone with my whole heart. I can have honest conversations, make difficult decisions, establish boundaries, and show up for the things that matter.

But I cannot make someone else choose differently.

I cannot force healing.

I cannot guarantee an outcome simply because I want it badly enough.

And I am beginning to understand that God never asked me to.

One of the tools I teach in coaching is called Mine, Theirs, and God's.

When something feels especially heavy, I take a moment to separate what belongs to me from what doesn't.

What's mine?

My thoughts, my choices, my behavior, my boundaries, and my willingness to seek God's direction.

What's theirs?

Their choices, their feelings, their actions, and how they decide to respond.

And what's God's?

The timing I cannot understand, the hearts I cannot change, and the parts of the story I cannot see.

It sounds simple, doesn't it?

And yet, I've discovered that identifying what belongs to God is much easier than actually leaving it with Him.

I've had moments when I've surrendered something in the temple, felt an incredible sense of peace, and then found myself worrying about that very same thing on the drive home.

Maybe you've done that too.

I think sometimes we imagine surrender as one beautiful, defining moment when we finally release everything and never struggle again.

But I'm discovering that surrender looks a little more ordinary than that.

Sometimes it happens in the middle of the night when my thoughts won't settle.

Sometimes it's choosing not to rehearse a conversation for the tenth time.

Sometimes it's allowing someone I love to make their own choices, even when I wish they would choose differently.

And sometimes it's simply whispering, "Heavenly Father, I don't know what to do with this. But I know You do."

I love the promise in Proverbs 3:5–6:

"Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding.

"In all thy ways acknowledge him, and he shall direct thy paths."

Notice that He promises to direct our paths.

Not necessarily to show us the entire journey.

And goodness, I would really like the entire journey sometimes.

I'd like to know which decisions will bring peace, which conversations will lead to understanding, and whether the things I'm praying for will turn out the way I hope.

But perhaps there is a reason God so often gives us light for only the next step.

Maybe He's teaching us to recognize His hand rather than rely entirely on our own understanding.

I think about the Israelites gathering manna in the wilderness. They were given enough for each day, with special provision for the Sabbath.

They couldn't store up a lifetime of reassurance.

They had to learn to trust that God would provide again.

And I wonder if that's what He's teaching me in this season.

To receive enough for today.

Enough courage for the conversation in front of me.

Enough wisdom to recognize what belongs to me.

Enough peace to leave tomorrow where it belongs.

In His hands.

There's something else I've been realizing, and this one feels particularly personal.

Sometimes I don't just want the situation to be okay.

I want to know that I'm going to be okay.

I want reassurance that I won't be hurt, that I won't make the wrong decision, and that the things I love won't slip away.

I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting those things.

But I'm learning that my peace cannot depend entirely on circumstances I cannot control.

Because if it does... I'll spend my life waiting for everyone and everything around me to change before I allow myself to feel it.

And I don't believe that's the life Heavenly Father wants for me.

He wants me to experience His presence right here.

In the middle of the uncertainty.

Before the answers come.

While I'm still learning.

That doesn't mean every situation should remain the same. Sometimes faith requires us to make changes, have difficult conversations, or walk a path we never expected.

Surrender doesn't mean ignoring what hurts or pretending everything is fine.

It means allowing God to guide what we do next instead of letting fear make the decision for us.

And that distinction matters to me.

Because I don't want to make choices simply to escape discomfort.

I want to make them because I've sought the Lord, listened for the Spirit, and found the courage to follow the direction I've been given.

Even when that direction unfolds one step at a time.

I wish I could tell you that I've finally taken off my cape and left it behind for good.

But the truth is, I still reach for it.

Especially when life feels uncertain.

There are days when I want to step in and fix things that aren't mine to fix. Days when I question whether I've done enough. Days when trusting God feels harder than trying to manage everything myself.

But I'm getting better at noticing.

And when I do, I'm learning to ask a different question.

Heavenly Father, what part of this is actually mine?

Sometimes the answer is to speak.

Sometimes it's to listen.

Sometimes it's to establish a boundary or take a step forward.

And sometimes the answer is to wait.

Not because nothing is happening, but because there are things God is working on that I cannot see.

I keep coming back to one beautiful truth.

I was never meant to be the Savior of the people I love.

That position is already filled.

And the same Savior who loves them is also watching over me.

He knows the prayers I haven't found words for yet. He understands the feelings I'm still sorting through. He sees the parts of my story that haven't made sense to me.

And He isn't asking me to figure them all out today.

He's asking me to come to Him.

To trust Him.

To allow Him to be God.

So perhaps taking off the cape isn't really about becoming less responsible or less loving.

Perhaps it's about finally understanding the difference between what love asks of us and what fear convinces us we must do.

Love can show up without taking over.

Love can speak truth without demanding agreement.

Love can remain genuine while allowing another person the agency God gave them.

And love can include caring for our own hearts, too.

That's something I'm still learning.

Maybe you are as well.

So if you're reading this today with something weighing heavily on your heart, I want to invite you to consider three questions.

What am I carrying that doesn't actually belong to me?

Am I trying to change something because I'm afraid of what might happen if I don't?

And what would it look like to trust God with the outcome while faithfully doing my part?

You don't need to have all the answers.

I certainly don't.

But maybe you could begin with one small act of surrender today.

One worry you stop rehearsing.

One outcome you stop trying to force.

One prayer where you simply say, "Heavenly Father, I trust You with what I cannot see."

And then allow yourself to rest in the knowledge that He is already there.

I don't know exactly what the next chapter of my story will look like.

But I do know who will be walking through it with me.

And perhaps that's enough for today.

The cape can come off.

I have a Savior.

And so do you.

xoAmber

Inspired in part by Lysa TerKeurst's book, Making Peace with What You Cannot Control.

Amber Insera

Amber Insera

Hi there, I’m Amber—the voice behind this blog. I’m a seeker, a listener, and someone who loves helping others find deeper connection and meaning in the everyday moments of life. I believe that God is present in all our moments, even the quiet, messy ones, and that our growth often happens in the places we least expect. Whether it’s through a whisper, a feeling, or an unexpected pause, I’m constantly learning to tune in and recognize His presence, even in the chaos of life. When I’m not writing, you’ll likely find me exploring new ideas, spending time with my family, or just reflecting on the ways I can grow and help others do the same. I’m passionate about faith, growth, and helping you navigate life’s ups and downs with grace, honesty, and a whole lot of heart. I’m so glad you’re here. I hope my words offer some peace, encouragement, and a sense of connection as you journey through your own path.

Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog